Marginal
groups and cultural boundaries: The case of the Greek "Roma"
and their spatial and social exclusion from the urban context
of the city
The overwhelming majority of Greek "Roma" people
live on the edges of the Greek cities of the 21st century,
in a state of absolute marginalization, to which they have
been led - mainly over the last few decades - by the country's
development model. This model, through its process of urbanization
of Greek society, has leveled cultural diversity and assimilated
cultural and social pluralism, creating new social relations
and balances.
The growth of the Greek cities forces the Romany communities
to relocate continually, as land uses change, land values
increase continually, and the Roma are driven out of their
homes which - for the most part, of course - were on public
or privately owned land.
In these circumstances, the already impoverished Romany
community becomes poorer still, losing its ability to generate
the necessary income for survival, while often finding itself
compelled to approach closer to the Greek cities, which
are developing as centres of economic growth where there
are opportunities for secondary employment. However, the
development of the urban centres, expanding the cities and
paving the way for new exploitation of the land (particularly
through the mechanism of antiparochi - the sale of land
to property developers in exchange for a share in the new
development) forces the "Roma" into less and less
satisfactory homes on the periphery of Greek cities, in
areas which bear the scars of environmental and urban decay
and neglect.
It is above all locations outside the city plan, industrial
zones, areas of unauthorized and anarchic construction,
areas where land is degraded and depreciated in various
ways, which attract socially excluded "Roma" groups
to set up their encampments, creating enclaves of poverty
and social exclusion, but above all creating the conditions
for increased social decline. These areas around the Greek
cities are characterized by what is usually a total lack
of the most basic infrastructures - both technical (water
supply, sewers, transport, etc.) and social (schools, medical
and social services, etc.).
The "Roma" communities live in a variety of different
accommodation, varying in terms of the kind of structure
(conventional house or makeshift construction) and its quality,
the degree of integration into the communal fabric, the
permanence and other characteristics of the location. The
following general categories of accommodation are to be
found:
- Camp in permanent location - huts, shacks, tents - used
all year round or seasonally
- Camp at shifting location within broader area, used all
year round or seasonally
- Camp featuring mixture of houses and makeshift constructions
(shacks, tents), usually in permanent use
- Neighbourhoods - mostly consisting of houses, permanently
occupied, often in run-down parts of the city
- Conventional houses or apartments scattered around the
urban fabric
Different problems are experienced in these various categories,
some of them shared with the general population (although
affecting the "Roma" more severely), some of them
affecting the "Roma" communities alone. These
problems can be grouped in the following general categories:
The aim of the Conference was the re-activation
of a forum for dialogue and consent among the different
parties of social dialogue: the Government, the Local Authorities,
the Rom citizens through their representing bodies and the
citizens active in the NGO field, in order to establish
alliances between the public and social front:
a) through the promotion of institutional and legislative
regulations and the provision of solutions for the implementation
of the National Scheme for the residential rehabilitation
of the homeless Rom, and
b) through organizing and disseminating the know-how for
the planning of an integrated methodology for problem solving
within the rational of social inclusion.
The proceedings of the Conference focused on the integrated
planning for the residential rehabilitation and the social
inclusion of Rom citizens, emphasizing on theoretical and
methodological documentation and in connecting it with actions
already taken and the current developments that could lead
to the implementation of the National Scheme. During the
Conference the moral basis of the social residence was illustrated,
as well as the institutional and legislative basis of the
issue, focusing on the special and numerous problems of
Rom homeless in Greece.
- Lack of housing
- Inadequacy of basic housing structure
- Planning system
- Property ownership system
- Inadequate technical and social infrastructure
- Lack of reception spaces for traveling “Roma”
- Inability to access housing support mechanisms
- Housing security
- Social rejection
The majority of the "Roma" population remains
marginalized, socially excluded, living in wretched conditions
in respect of their housing within the city limits and of
their access to basic social rights and commodities. This
state of affairs generates the conditions for general and
extreme (as a matter of actual physical survival) social
exclusion, and all its consequences: absolute poverty and
the struggle to survive, exclusion from institutions and
social rights, isolation and introversion.
It is absolutely certain that these conditions cannot be
tackled through suppression, or greater contraction of the
"Roma" peoples' rights, or by intensification
of their spatial and social exclusion - as has been the
case in the past, and continues to be the case today. These
phenomena can be reversed only by organized and long-term
policies for inclusion.
Social exclusion and cultural segregation are both born
in the same environment: the basic cell of 'social biology'
- the 'neighbourhood'. At the level of the "neighbourhood",
and especially the "neighbourhood in crisis",
of urban exclusion, characterized by poverty, unemployment,
the lack of infrastructures, the absence of social support
mechanisms, with all their consequences, the divorce from
local social institutions, criminality, the same vicious
circle of exclusion and cultural segregation is produced
and re-produced. And with each cycle of exclusion the balance
is further reduced, eventually leading to a state of complete
social annihilation.
For this reason, any actions and initiatives must focus
on the neighbourhood as their key point of reference. In
neighbourhoods where the "Roma" people live initiatives
need to be launched to promote mutual recognition and acceptance
of all inhabitants. Each action must seek to create permanent,
small institutions to highlight Romany cultural identity
and to promote and ensure the organic inclusion of the "Roma"
into structures and activities at local community level.
Each action must create a meeting point for different cultures,
an opportunity for social involvement, dialogue and debate
- the ultimate objective being the mutual acceptance and
understanding of citizens on the level of the neighbourhood
and the local community.